• Focus Areas
    • Cause Selection
    • Global Health & Wellbeing
      • Effective Altruism Community Growth (Global Health and Wellbeing)
      • Farm Animal Welfare
      • Global Aid Policy
      • Global Health & Development
      • Scientific Research
      • South Asian Air Quality
    • Longtermism
      • Biosecurity & Pandemic Preparedness
      • Effective Altruism Community Growth (Longtermism)
      • Potential Risks from Advanced AI
    • Other Areas
      • Criminal Justice Reform
      • History of Philanthropy
      • Immigration Policy
      • Land Use Reform
      • Macroeconomic Stabilization Policy
  • Grants
  • Research & Updates
    • Research Reports
    • Blog Posts
    • Notable Lessons
    • In the News
  • About Us
    • Grantmaking Process
    • How to Apply for Funding
    • Team
    • Contact Us
    • Stay Updated
  • We’re hiring!
  • Focus Areas
    • Cause Selection
    • Global Health & Wellbeing
      • Effective Altruism Community Growth (Global Health and Wellbeing)
      • Farm Animal Welfare
      • Global Aid Policy
      • Global Health & Development
      • Scientific Research
      • South Asian Air Quality
    • Longtermism
      • Biosecurity & Pandemic Preparedness
      • Effective Altruism Community Growth (Longtermism)
      • Potential Risks from Advanced AI
    • Other Areas
      • Criminal Justice Reform
      • History of Philanthropy
      • Immigration Policy
      • Land Use Reform
      • Macroeconomic Stabilization Policy
  • Grants
  • Research & Updates
    • Research Reports
    • Blog Posts
    • Notable Lessons
    • In the News
  • About Us
    • Grantmaking Process
    • How to Apply for Funding
    • Team
    • Contact Us
    • Stay Updated
  • We’re hiring!

Machine Intelligence Research Institute — General Support (2017)

Visit Grantee Site
  • Focus Area: Potential Risks from Advanced AI
  • Organization Name: Machine Intelligence Research Institute
  • Amount: $3,750,000

  • Award Date: October 2017

Table of Contents

    Researchers at the Machine Intelligence Research Institute. (Photo courtesy of MIRI)
    Grant investigator: Nick Beckstead
    This page was reviewed but not written by the grant investigator. MIRI staff also reviewed this page prior to publication.

    The Open Philanthropy Project recommended a grant of $3,750,000 over three years to the Machine Intelligence Research Institute (MIRI) for general support. MIRI plans to use these funds for ongoing research and activities related to reducing potential risks from advanced artificial intelligence, one of our focus areas.

    This grant represents a renewal of and increase to our $500,000 grant recommendation to MIRI in 2016, which we made despite strong reservations about their research agenda, detailed here. In short, we saw value in MIRI’s work but decided not to recommend a larger grant at that time because we were unconvinced of the value of MIRI’s research approach to AI safety relative to other research directions, and also had difficulty evaluating the technical quality of their research output. Additionally, we felt a large grant might signal a stronger endorsement from us than was warranted at the time, particularly as we had not yet made many grants in this area.

    Our decision to renew and increase MIRI’s funding sooner than expected was largely the result of the following:

    • We received a very positive review of MIRI’s work on “logical induction” by a machine learning researcher who (i) is interested in AI safety, (ii) is rated as an outstanding researcher by at least one of our close advisors, and (iii) is generally regarded as outstanding by the ML community. As mentioned above, we previously had difficulty evaluating the technical quality of MIRI’s research, and we previously could find no one meeting criteria (i) – (iii) to a comparable extent who was comparably excited about MIRI’s technical research. While we would not generally offer a comparable grant to any lab on the basis of this consideration alone, we consider this a significant update in the context of the original case for the grant (especially MIRI’s thoughtfulness on this set of issues, value alignment with us, distinctive perspectives, and history of work in this area). While the balance of our technical advisors’ opinions and arguments still leaves us skeptical of the value of MIRI’s research, the case for the statement “MIRI’s research has a nontrivial chance of turning out to be extremely valuable (when taking into account how different it is from other research on AI safety)” appears much more robust than it did before we received this review.
    • In the time since our initial grant to MIRI, we have recommended several more grants within this focus area, and are therefore less concerned that a larger grant will signal an outsized endorsement of MIRI’s approach.

    We are now aiming to support about half of MIRI’s annual budget. MIRI expects to use these funds mostly toward salaries of MIRI researchers, research engineers, and support staff.

    Related Items

    • Potential Risks from Advanced AI

      Machine Intelligence Research Institute — General Support (2020)

      Open Philanthropy recommended a grant of $7,703,750 to the Machine Intelligence Research Institute (MIRI) for general support. MIRI plans to use these funds for ongoing research and activities...

      Read more
    • Potential Risks from Advanced AI

      Machine Intelligence Research Institute — General Support (2019)

      The Open Philanthropy Project recommended a grant of $2,652,500 over two years to the Machine Intelligence Research Institute (MIRI) for general support. MIRI plans to use these funds...

      Read more
    • Potential Risks from Advanced AI

      Machine Intelligence Research Institute — AI Safety Retraining Program

      The Open Philanthropy Project recommended a grant of $150,000 to the Machine Intelligence Research Institute (MIRI) to support its artificial intelligence safety (AI) retraining project. MIRI intends to...

      Read more
    Back to Grants Database
    Open Philanthropy
    Open Philanthropy
    • Careers
    • Press Kit
    • Governance
    • Privacy Policy
    • Stay Updated
    Mailing Address
    Open Philanthropy
    182 Howard Street #225
    San Francisco, CA 94105
    Email
    [email protected]
    Media Inquiries
    [email protected]
    Anonymous Feedback
    Feedback Form

    © Open Philanthropy 2022 Except where otherwise noted, this work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 4.0 International License. If you'd like to translate this content into another language, please get in touch!